Fans are split on Lily Collins' Netflix Inheritance movie

Lily Collins and Patrick Warburton in Inheritance
Lily Collins and Patrick Warburton in Inheritance (Image credit: Ingenious Media/Convergent Media/Highland Film Group (HFG)/Southpaw Entertainment/White Comet Films/TCD/Prod.DB/Alamy Stock Photo)

Though Netflix has been making great strides with its slate of original films, the popular streaming service is still a good place for viewers to discover older movies they may have missed the first time around. Such is the case with 2020’s Inheritance movie starring Lily Collins.

Inheritance is a mystery thriller that centers on Lauren (Collins), who is given the keys to a hidden bunker on her wealthy family’s estate following the death of her father. What she finds in that bunker, however, could destroy her family. In addition to Collins, the movie stars Simon Pegg (Shaun of the Dead), Connie Nielsen (Wonder Woman), Chace Crawford (The Boys), Marque Richardson (Dear White People), Michael Beach (Dahmer) and Patrick Warburton (Seinfeld).

The movie arrived on Netflix on September 28 and since has really taken off in the US, with the movie ranking as high as the second most popular movie on the streaming service since its release, even besting the controversial Marilyn Monroe movie Blonde for a number of days.

However, just because people are watching the movie does not mean that it is becoming a cult classic. In fact, opinions on the movie seem to be right down the middle — those who love it and its dark twists versus those who are calling it one of the worst movies they’ve ever seen.

Here’s a sampling of what people are saying about Inheritance:

There are a few, however, who seem to be able to straddle the line and appreciate Inheritance despite what some see as its faults: 

If we look back to what was said about Inheritance back when it was released, the movie reviews show it wasn't well received. Critics gave it 24% on Rotten Tomatoes, with the audience score not much better, at 33%. Peter Travers of Rolling Stone called the movie "a blithering botch job of a thriller" in his review.

But this latest streaming release on Netflix shows that the movie is finding a second life, even if the overall opinion is still split. You have to admit that is arguably one of the best things about streaming services — their ability to allow movies and TV shows to find their audiences.

Inheritance is only available to stream on Netflix right now (which of course requires a subscription to the streaming service), though it is leaving Netflix in the UK on October 5 so if you want to catch it, you'll need to be quick! The movie is also available to rent via digital on-demand, though with those review scores you might not want to pay the extra. 

Check out the trailer to get a peek at some of what the fuss is about:

CATEGORIES
Michael Balderston
Assistant Managing Editor

Michael Balderston is What to Watch’s assistant managing editor and lead movie writer, covering movies coming to theaters, writing movie reviews and highlighting new and classic movies on streaming services; he also covers a range of TV shows, including those in the Taylor Sheridan universe, Slow Horses, Only Murders in the Building, Jeopardy!, Saturday Night Live and more, as well as the best ways to watch some major US sporting events.

Based outside of Washington, D.C., Michael's previous experience includes writing for Awards Circuit, TV Technology and The Wrap.

Michael’s favorite movie of all time is Casablanca, while his favorite TV show is Seinfeld. Some 2025 favorites include One of Them Days and Black Bag for movies, and The Pitt on TV. Follow on Letterboxd to keep up with what I'm watching.

News
Stay updated by following
What to Watch