Take Two: Andrew Garfield vs Florence Pugh
Pitting the We Live in Time co-stars with a series of 50/50 questions about their careers.

Andrew Garfield and Florence Pugh might fall in love in their new movie We Live in Time, but in our latest version of Take Two we're having the two co-stars square off to see who comes out on top in a series of 50/50 questions about their career, including whose breakout movie has a higher Rotten Tomatoes score and which of them was the first to receive an Oscar nomination? The game is pretty simple, we'll give you a prompt and all you have to do is guess whether Garfield or Pugh is the right answer. Here are the questions:
- Whose breakout movie has a higher Rotten Tomatoes score: Garfield's Boy A or Pugh's Lady Macbeth?
- Who has the highest rated movie on IMDb's Top 250 list: Garfield's Spider-Man: No Way Home of Pugh's Dune: Part Two?
- Whose Netflix original movie has a higher Rotten Tomatoes score: Garfield's tick, tick... BOOM! or Pugh's The Wonder?
- Who was the first to earn an Oscar nomination: Garfield or Pugh?
- Which TV series has a higher Rotten Tomatoes score: Garfield's Under the Banner of Heaven or Pugh's The Little Drummer Girl?
Play an interactive version of game below to get an official score on how many you can get right (all you have to do is type in the appropriate name). Official answers and more details on each are available right here.
If you enjoyed that, check out more games from What to Watch:
- Take Two: M. Night Shyamalan
- Take Two: Channing Tatum
- Take Two: Winona Ryder
- Take Two: English Remake vs International Original
- Take Two: George Clooney vs Brad Pitt
We Live in Time releases in select US movie theaters on October 11 and then hits theaters nationwide on October 18. For those in the UK the movie releases on January 1, 2025. Here are more details on how to watch We Live in Time.
Check out the official answers, with some additional insight into each, right here:
Get the What to Watch Newsletter
The latest updates, reviews and unmissable series to watch and more!

Michael Balderston is What to Watch’s assistant managing editor and lead movie writer, covering movies coming to theaters, writing movie reviews and highlighting new and classic movies on streaming services; he also covers a range of TV shows, including those in the Taylor Sheridan universe, Slow Horses, Only Murders in the Building, Jeopardy!, Saturday Night Live and more, as well as the best ways to watch some major US sporting events.
Based outside of Washington, D.C., Michael's previous experience includes writing for Awards Circuit, TV Technology and The Wrap.
Michael’s favorite movie of all time is Casablanca, while his favorite TV show is Seinfeld. Some 2025 favorites include One of Them Days and Black Bag for movies, and The Pitt on TV. Follow on Letterboxd to keep up with what I'm watching.